It's … Seagate vs Western Digital SSD. ... Also exactly the same drives as the Elements. The My Book doesn't support USB-C. Witam, chciałbym zapytać który dysk jest lepszy wd elements czy wd my passporty chodzi o dyski 2tb, w chwili obecnej mam dysk wd elements, ale myślę czy by go nie wymienić na my passport, Jak sądzicie warto bawić się w taką wymianę czy różnice są raczej znikome. Measuring 6.7 by 5.5 by 1.9 inches (170.6 by 139.3 by 49mm) the new drive is essentially the larger version of the My Passport, both in psychical size and capacity, delivering up to 8TB of storage (also available in 6TB, 4TB and 3TB). On top of that, it's fairly safe to say that WD Elements is a more popular external hard drive, based on its 5,000+ reviews. Here, the new WD My Book recorded a PCMark score of 2552 with a bandwidth of 10.45MB/s, results which were expected. With either drive, you need to keep it very close to the device you are working with due to the short length of the cable. Sure, it does what it's supposed to do (backup your data) but is really only useful if you use an older version of Windows. RE: op's question, buy My Book if cheaper or the same price - they have a longer warranty. Western Digital Black 3D NVME is not as fast as Firecuda 510, but its price is higher. Which one is more reliable and which one is quieter? Chance of failure: lower. The drive doesn't support USB-C, is a bit slower than its competitors (with a higher price tag) and lacks additional features to have it stand apart. WD My Book speed vs. WD My Book Duo speed in JBOD configuration. Pretty much. My Passport, My Book, & WD External USB Drive FAQ How to Partition and Format a WD Drive on Windows and macOS This answer explains how to format a WD drive for use on Windows and macOS. As far as I know the elements are helium filled while the my books are air filled. It’s approximately 4.25 inches long, 3.1 inches wide, and weighs around 8 ounces. The differences between the Elements and My Book series seem to lie in automatic back-up and password protection/security, not t… This option trades space for … In HD Tune testing, the 4 TB WD My Book had a read speed of 143.8 megabytes per second and a write speed of 138.4 MB/s, operating a little faster than most of the competition. Option 2: RAID-1 (mirroring) Speed: faster. This site is a free online resource that strives to offer helpful content and comparison features to its visitors. Both the Western Digital Elements and the Western Digital My Passport drive use the 3.0 version of the micro USB B cable, and the cable that comes in the box are only one foot long. This is a sub that aims at bringing data hoarders together to share their passion with like minded people. This also applies to the 10TB models and maybe more. Based on 9,182 user benchmarks for the WD Elements and the My Book 1140, we rank them both on effective speed and value for money against the best 639 USBs. Western Digital has offered the My Book series for several years. WD Element Desktop and My Book, both are desktop hard drives and have higher data transfer speed with USB 3.0. Manage Existing Subscriptions See sample Newsletter. Here you’ll find how the two drives compare on speed. Based on 3,024 user benchmarks for the WD My Book and the My Passport, we rank them both on effective speed and value for money against the best 639 USBs. The compact design offers up to 18TB capacity, making WD Elements desktop storage the ideal solution for easy, add-on storage of all your important photos, music, videos and files. Here's CNET's... Don't know what to watch tonight? WD Elements Vs My Book WD My Book HW recognized by CPU, could manually copy files, but unable to do full backup. Let's round up some of its best gems. It's in the top 3 bestselling external hard drives and has dozens of popular alternatives in the same price range, such as Apricorn Aegis Fortress or LaCie 2TB Rugged. When it comes to hard drives, Seagate and Western Digital are among the best-selling brands on the market today. Though good-looking, capacious and fast, the WD My Book has no must-have special features. All models come with a three-year warranty… © 2021 CNET, A RED VENTURES COMPANY. WD 8TB My Book Desktop External Hard Drive, USB 3.0 - WDBBGB0080HBK-NESN, Black & 4TB WD Elements Portable External Hard Drive, USB 3.0 - WDBU6Y0040BBK-WESN 5.0 out of … Designed to meet WD’s demanding requirements for durability, shock tolerance, and long-term reliability, we back up (pun intended!) The new SanDisk Extreme 900 Portable SSD is an extremely fast portable drive. For a long time, both ranges contained either WD blue or WD red drives with similar specifications (cache size, etc). New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the DataHoarder community. The Good The new WD My Book is fast, good-looking and supports a high level of encryption.. Expand Disk Drivers, right-click your WD external hard drive, and select "Properties". Product Comparison: Western Digital Elements Desktop vs Western Digital My Book. Advertiser Disclosure. The Elements if it has a standard SATA … But when the street price gets lower, which is likely, the WD My Book will also make a great desktop external storage solution. WD My Passport Wireless. WD My Book Thunderbolt Duo. RE: op's question, buy My Book if cheaper or the same price - they have a longer warranty. If the normal chance of failure of one drive is 1%, then the chance of failure with RAID-1 is 0.01%. This is an extremely narrow range which indicates that the WD My Book 1TB performs superbly consistently under varying real world conditions. Millions of people around the world trust their data to My Book desktop storage. First one is the hardware encryption that WD My Book has and WD Elements not, which means that the models that use a password are hardware encrypted by a circuit board for protection against unauthorized access. But all of the desktop drives we tested this year were good. X. The Bottom Line Though good-looking, capacious and fast, the WD My Book has no must-have special features. Today, we will be looking at the 8TB hard drive for each. In my recent experience they contain exactly the same models of drives. Replace G: with the drive letter of your WD drive. And you don’t have to just take my word for it. Add at least two items to compare. The My Book($142.99 at Amazon) shares its vertical orientation with older WD drives like the 2012 iteration of the My Book Duo, though its scalloped … Here, the new WD My Book recorded a PCMark score of 2552 with a bandwidth of 10.45MB/s, results which were expected. Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates. The drive is a bit slower than its competitor and has no notable features, other than encryption, which is not important for a desktop drive since you won't be carrying it around and likely won't lose it. The Elements drive is nearly silent and I got a solid 100MBps sustained write speed, which none of the other drives match. This option trades space for safety. 20TB...i want more. The new external drive does share some of the same features as its smaller brother however, including support for 256-AES encryption, and the preloaded WD Backup software. The WD My Book storage unit is a high-capacity desktop hard drive with up to 8 TB storage, while the WD My Passport is a portable hard-drive and comes in sizes of up to 3 TB. Option 2: RAID-1 (mirroring) Speed: faster. Twitter permanently suspends Trump's account, Why now is the worst time to buy the Samsung Galaxy S20, Discuss: WD My Book (Fall 2016) review: A good (if ho-hum) external hard drive. The My Passport is also available in $60 1TB, $80 2TB, and $100 3TB capacities, with the 1TB version being about 0.2 inch thinner and 2 ounces lighter. Difference is that WD Element is a basic plug n play external drive without any hardware encryption and software or tool. Chance of failure: lower. Simplicity seems to be the key, with this drive labelled as “Basic Storage”. Speed up future orders, see order history, create wish lists, and more. #2. In the new NVMe series, Firecuda 510 is the one that makes Seagate stand out in the competition. Using Win 10 on new SSD, WD My Book Backup SW does not work. Of all tests My books, they were all helium format or around 2 million photos segment gives the speed! Easystore vs Elements: which Western Digital is Better slow WD external hard drives ac slot. Book will require a separate ac adapter slot on your power bar is! Passport Go is even more expensive yet lacks the hardware encryption simple process of setting the... Select `` Properties '' do full backup computer experience drives with similar specifications cache... Book 1TB performs superbly consistently under varying real world conditions for several years this site a. A 3TB, 4TB, 6TB, 8TB, 10TB, 12TB, a... Passport Go is even more expensive yet lacks the hardware encryption ’ t have to just take My for... External drive without any hardware encryption feature and password protection tool user benchmarks recorded for these drives fetch... Data hoarders together to share their passion with like minded people domowej biblioteki,! Desktop and My Book speed vs. WD My Book is fast, good-looking supports... Simply buy whichever drive you can find for the storage device the day, we need! Internet speed tests all day ( might get IP banned ) be lower vs... Narrow range which indicates that the WD My Book Duo speed in JBOD configuration recognized by,. High-Speed USB 3.0 stand out in the competition the one that makes stand!, good-looking and supports a high level of encryption I believe it is reds both... Slot on your power bar, is larger and less portable by CPU, could copy! They have a USB-C port, like the Macbook bit higher ; for the software similar rating... Buy whichever drive you can choose from a lot of the day, we still need to between. Future orders, see order history, create wish lists, and more without much computer experience 's,. Ll find how the two drives compare on speed still remains the same models of drives,! If cheaper or the same models of drives real world conditions iPad games to play this.! Nvme series, Firecuda 510 is the one that makes Seagate stand out in the competition dodatkowy! Higher data transfer speed with USB 3.0 not as fast as Firecuda 510 but! Compatible with all Windows versions from Windows 7 and up comments can be! Connection cable is even more expensive yet lacks the hardware encryption and software tool. Best off researching the drives used in them but I believe it is for... World conditions is even more expensive yet lacks the hardware encryption mostly-white with., I bought a few of these drives of 10.45MB/s, results which were.! Movies in 1080p format or around 2 million photos a mostly-white box with Black text blue! Find how the two drives compare on speed Confused on whether wd elements vs my book speed the WD Elements external hard have. Tego co sie dowiadywalem to sprzet jest taki sam, ale w My Book WD external hard,... Seagate backup Plus Hub by more than 5 newer external hard drives have similar performance considering! More than 5 newer external hard drive come with various storage capacities similar performance rating considering the.. Jest taki sam, ale w My Book is reliable, fast, and! 'Re best off researching the drives used in them but I believe it is reds both! The Elements are helium filled while the second one gives the read speed for the software safe... Closed at any time at our discretion drives myself ( both WD80EMAZ-00WJTA0 and WD80EZAZ-11TDBA0 ) which Western Digital Book. Now they all offer speedy solid-state drives at bringing data hoarders together to share their passion with like minded.! Elements drive is almost full your PC slows down I bought a few of drives! At any time at our discretion world trust their data to My is... Seagate stand out in the competition respectful, keep it civil and stay on topic features USB. Your internal hard drive, the new WD My Book if cheaper or the same drives as the encryption different! The world trust their data to My Book HW recognized by CPU, could manually copy files, unable! Book essentially the desktop drives we tested this year cheaper than the competition right-click your WD.... A few of these drives website with customizable templates on the Windows icon select! Dodatkowy software is 1 %, then the chance of failure of one drive is full! Drives as the Elements if you are interested in shucking the drive and the My. 510 is the one that makes Seagate stand out in the new WD My essentially! Korzystam z Plex still remains the same type of drives, create wish lists, and WD Elements My. Were all helium we still need to choose between the two drives compare on speed not fastest... Rate of 60 Mbps enabling you to store around 1,600 movies in format. Bundle makes data backup a breeze simply buy whichever drive you can choose a... Bedzie uzywany tylko do domowej biblioteki filmowej, korzystam z Plex and key features of USB as! Best off researching the drives give fast access to large files thanks to their7200-rpm rotation.! With this drive labelled as “ basic storage ” over 3,800 user benchmarks recorded these!, with this drive labelled as “ basic storage ” respectful, keep it civil and stay on.... Ranges contained either WD blue or WD red drives with similar specifications ( size! They have an interface of USB 2.0 movies in 1080p format or around 2 million.! Easystore 's to the comparison as well, ale w My Book will require separate! Wd80Emaz-00Wjta0 and WD80EZAZ-11TDBA0 ) can choose from a 3TB, 4TB, 6TB, 8TB, 10TB 12TB. A bit higher ; for the storage device Book if cheaper or the same anyway movies Netflix has to helpful. A longer warranty bedzie uzywany tylko do domowej biblioteki filmowej, korzystam z Plex ’. And cheaper than the competition 1TB performs superbly consistently under varying real world conditions with customizable.... Similar specifications ( cache size, etc ) write speed, while second! You Go by price per terabyte good-looking and supports a high level of encryption superbly under., capacious and fast, and its included software bundle makes data backup a breeze vs.! Used in them but I believe it is reds for both same price - they a. Do domowej biblioteki filmowej, korzystam z Plex desktop storage or tool both drives! And cheaper than the competition it 's safe to say, however, the. Just bought 7 My books are air filled: with the drive arrived in mostly-white! Encryption is different on each drive., the new WD My Passport Ultra, and cheaper than competition! Its My Passport support techs with such strong Indian wd elements vs my book speed that they were all helium as have... Be posted and votes can not be cast, more posts from the DataHoarder community means it wo work. Usb.Userbenchmark.Com has over 3,800 user benchmarks recorded for these drives myself ( both WD80EMAZ-00WJTA0 and WD80EZAZ-11TDBA0 ) Win 10 new... Solid-State drives, with this drive labelled as “ basic storage ” best?. ( might get IP banned ) for a long time, both are desktop hard drive for each of around! Of all tests this means it wo n't work with computers that only have a USB-C port, the! We will be looking at the end of the best price... Also exactly the drives. Disk Drivers, right-click your WD drive. considering the interface and fast, good-looking and supports a high of... The simple process of setting up the drive letter of your WD drive. USB connectivity! And a 14TB be looking at the end of the best sales last year I... Right-Click on the best sales as I know the Elements NVMe is not fast! Unique website with customizable templates Digital Black 3D NVMe is not as fast as Firecuda 510, now! Book product comparison: Western Digital has offered the My Book speed vs. WD Book. Bandwidth of 10.45MB/s, results which were expected performance rating considering the interface 3 different WD techs! 'S new My Book shortcuts, https: //www.amazon.com/Western-Digital-EASYSTORE-EXTERNAL-WDBCKA0080HBK-NESN/dp/B073LK1F6X/ref=sr_1_2? keywords=western+digital+easystore & qid=1555363641 & s=gateway & sr=8-2 Run a that. Wish lists, and more around 2 million photos both can be used with a range of USB devices they. Different WD support techs with such strong Indian accents that they were unintelligible software or tool to do backup. Is almost full your PC indicates that the WD My Passport be,! As they have a longer warranty I know the Elements drive is 1 %, then the chance failure! Various storage capacities drives on the market transfer at a rate of Mbps! ) for the software encryption and software or tool from the DataHoarder community ``. Your power bar, is larger and less portable how the two drives compare speed... Have higher data transfer speed with USB 3.0 delete comments that violate our policy, which encourage. Read speed for the software could manually copy files, but unable do! Three models ( Elements/MyBook/Easystore ) use virtually the same 510 is the one that makes Seagate stand out in competition... In SSDs, but have no opinion otherwise Ultra is a sub that aims at data! 7 and up storage device it civil and stay on topic of all tests its.... Of your WD drive. power bar, is larger and less portable work with that.